Log In

New York Bourbon

Updated: Oct. 12, 2018

In the past few years, bourbons made in New York state have gained popularity. Distillers in New York are innovating on long-held traditions, altering distillation methods, recipes, mashbills, and more. Whether you’re seeking something sweet and smooth or a bourbon that’s more on the bitter side, we’ve searched all over the internet to find a bourbon that’s right for you.

Our team assessed insights from every perspective that matters—from real consumers and trusted experts to brands and retailers. Our findings are laid out so that you can home in on the criteria that’s most essential to you.

New York Bourbon

In the past few years, bourbons made in New York state have gained popularity. Distillers in New York are innovating on long-held traditions, altering distillation methods, recipes, mashbills, and more. Whether you’re seeking something sweet and smooth or a bourbon that’s more on the bitter side, we’ve searched all over the internet to find a bourbon that’s right for you.

Our team assessed insights from every perspective that matters—from real consumers and trusted experts to brands and retailers. Our findings are laid out so that you can home in on the criteria that’s most essential to you.

The Quid Pick

Tuthilltown Spirits Hudson Baby Bourbon

In 2005, Tuthilltown Spirits spearheaded the revival of New York's small batch spirits production, which had been abandoned during Prohibition. The distillery's crowd-pleasing yet nuanced Hudson Baby Bourbon is crafted from a 100% corn mash bill, which gives it a light sweetness and deep ambor hue. The floral notes complement warm ginger undertones for a satisfying finish.

Quid Score

87

|

Lowest Price

$56

Top Ten New York Bourbon

The Quid Pick might not be ideal for everyone. Different people have different tastes. Here are the Quiddity-approved Top 10 New York Bourbons.

Our methodology

Frequently Asked Questions

What is bourbon?

Bourbon is whiskey distilled from a mash that has at least 51% corn. It must be produced in America.

What is the difference between whiskey and bourbon?

Bourbon is a subcategory of whiskey, but not all whiskey is bourbon. Whiskey in general is a spirit distilled from grain mash. This mash can consist of barley, corn, rye, and/or wheat. Whiskey can be made all over the world, but its grain selection and where it’s produced determine the type of whiskey it is. Bourbon is a type of whiskey that is distilled from at least 51% corn, and is distilled in America.

Does bourbon have to be made in Kentucky?

No. Sure, 95% of bourbon comes from Kentucky, according to the Kentucky Distillers Association. But by law it doesn’t have to be made the Bluegrass State. It just has to be made, per the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, in America “from a fermented mash of not less than 51 percent corn.”

Where can I buy Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey?

Tuthilltown Hudson Bay Baby Bourbon can be purchased in most liquor stores or online through Total Wine where available.

What’s the difference between Kentucky and New York bourbon?

Most New York bourbon distilleries are relatively new, so their bourbons can lack the aging quality that Kentucky bourbons have. New York distilleries, however, can be more creative in mashbills and distillation, giving them a different taste than their Kentucky cousins.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Hello, friend.

Please enter a valid email address